At the risk of sounding like Emily Litella – that cranky old Gilda Radner character who never quite knew what was going on – sometimes Miss Communications simply feels the need to ask: What’s all this about “its” and “it’s”?
It’s amazing how many well-educated grown-ups – people who presumably passed eighth-grade English and now hold actual jobs – simply fall apart when they’re faced with this three-letter word. When does it need an apostrophe, they wonder, and when does it not? And when it does, where does the little sucker go?
When it comes to apostrophizing “its,” there are all sorts of reasons it’s confusing, and its confusion has a lot to do with the rules we’ve learned. We were taught that when a noun is possessive, we use an apostrophe and an “s” to show it. Thus the room of Emily becomes “Emily’s room” and the drawings on the shoes of Kylee become “Kylee’s shoes’ designs.”
But for this little word, it’s the exception that creates its difficulty.
“It” is treated differently, and as many people remember – but far too many forget – “it” doesn’t take an apostrophe when it’s possessive. Therefore the stuff within a museum becomes “its art collection,” and that early morning racket from your neighbor’s dog may someday – we can hope – become “its last woof.”
How can the average e-mailer and slide-creator keep track of the apostrophized “it’s”? It’s actually pretty simple when you consider its logic: You use an apostrophe when “it’s” is short for “it is” or “it has.” Thus, it’s a beautiful day for a grammar lesson, and it’s been wonderful to let Miss Communications’ inner grammar nut run wild.
Of course, it’s all good and well to remind people that written language has its rules, as foggy as they may be. But it’s even more valuable to provide a handy-dandy way to commit its rules to memory.
Some say the best way to remember that the possessive “its” has no apostrophe is to compare it to “his,” “hers,” and “yours.” Those are possessive pronouns, too, and hardly anyone tries to sneak a punctuation mark into them.
As for using “it’s” correctly, compare “it is” and “it has” with “they are” and “we have.” They’re also contractions, and we’ve noticed that people pretty consistently remember to add apostrophes where the missing letters (and spaces) once were.
Now, what about that oddball freak of English where folks decide to put an apostrophe at the end of “its,” as in “its’ ”? Most of us know that no such word exists, but for those who are unconvinced, we can only suggest looking it up in a dictionary, where it’s certain you’ll discover its absence.
If you’ve got a pet language peeve and you think it’s worth its weight in ink, write to Miss Communications with your rant. If it’s a good and sensible one, we’ll share its wisdom with the world. And if it’s not? Then as Miss Litella would have said, never mind.
This classic Miss Communications column was originally published February 22nd, 2008, and was awarded first place for "Specialized Columns" by Colorado Press Women as well as the National Federation of Press Women. Unfortunately, the column's title was mis-punctuated on the CPW award. Surely there's a joke in there somewhere.